Why You Shouldn’t Rely Solely on Reviews When Choosing a Riding Instructor

Why Opinions About Riding Instructors Aren’t Always Accurate

Choosing the right riding instructor is a major decision for any equestrian. Whether you’re a new rider looking to start your journey or a seasoned competitor seeking to improve, finding a trainer who fits your goals and learning style is essential. However, relying too heavily on other people’s opinions—or even online reviews—can lead you astray.

Here’s why opinions about riding instructors aren’t always the most reliable guide, and how to make a more informed choice for yourself.


1. Different Riders, Different Goals

What works for one rider may not work for another. Some equestrians are looking to compete at high levels, while others want a safe, supportive environment to gain confidence. A riding coach who pushes competitive athletes might not be the best fit for a casual or nervous rider—and vice versa.


2. Experience Shapes Perspective

Beginner riders often lack the experience to accurately assess the quality of instruction. They may praise a coach who’s friendly and encouraging, even if the instruction lacks depth or technical accuracy. Conversely, a demanding but highly effective trainer may receive mixed feedback simply because they challenge students in ways that feel uncomfortable at first.


3. Barn Politics and Personal Bias

Let’s face it—barn culture can be tricky. Interpersonal drama, favoritism, and even fallouts can color someone’s opinion of a trainer. A negative review might stem from a personality clash rather than poor instruction. It’s important to read between the lines and recognize when barn politics might be at play.


4. Fear of Speaking Honestly

The equestrian world is a small one. Many riders hesitate to speak candidly about a trainer, especially if they’re still part of the same local scene. This can result in sugarcoated reviews or vague comments that don’t offer real insight.


5. No Universal Standard for “Good Instruction”

Every rider has a different definition of what makes a great trainer. Some prioritize safety and encouragement. Others value technical precision and competitive results. The problem? There’s no single standard for what qualifies as “good instruction”—and that makes personal reviews highly subjective.



How to Choose the Right Riding Instructor for You

So, how can you make a smart choice without relying too much on word-of-mouth or internet reviews? Here are a few tips:

• Watch a lesson before committing. Observe how the trainer communicates and how students respond.
• Take a trial ride if possible. See how their teaching style fits with your learning preferences.
• Ask specific questions about the trainer’s approach, experience, and student progression.
• Trust your instincts. You know best what kind of environment helps you thrive.

Final Thoughts

When it comes to riding instruction, opinions are just that—opinions. Use them as a starting point, not the final word. Finding the right instructor is a personal process, and the best decision is the one that fits you and your horse.


At Hebert Sport Horses, we encourage riders to explore their options with confidence and clarity. Whether you’re auditing a lesson or visiting our facility, we’re here to help you make an informed, empowered choice.